Threecolts Threecolts
PricingPricing
Log In Log In Get Started Get Started
  • Margin Pro
  • Retail 365New
  • AI OperatorNew
  • Seller 365
  • UniCon
  • Onsite Support
  • Online Arbitrage
  • Retail Arbitrage
  • Wholesale
  • BrandsNew
  • 1P Vendors
  • 3P Sellers
  • Blog
  • Knowledge Base
  • Threecolts University
  • Wall of Love
Pricing
Log In Log In Get Started Get Started
Margin Pro Find and recover margin lost to deductions, fees, and overcharges. Retail 365New One connected view of your Amazon Vendor P&L. AI OperatorNew Automate routine seller operations with an always-on AI teammate. UniCon Launch and manage your catalog on major marketplaces. Onsite Support Turn every support ticket into an operational workspace.
Seller 365 Run your entire seller operation with ten tools in one subscription.
  • InventoryLab
  • Tactical Arbitrage
  • FeedbackWhiz Emails
  • FeedbackWhiz Alerts
  • FeedbackWhiz Profits
  • SmartRepricer
  • InventoryLab Accounting
  • ScoutIQ
  • Scoutify
  • ScoutX
Business model
  • Online Arbitrage
  • Retail Arbitrage
  • Wholesale
  • BrandsNew
Fulfillment model
  • 1P Vendors
  • 3P Sellers
Services
  • Vendor Recovery
  • Seller Reimbursements
  • Carrier Optimization
Case Study David Protein’s frictionless expansion story. Case Study How Acquco recovered $3M in hidden margin. Case Study How Modway saved $2.7M with zero risk.
Learn
  • Blog
  • Podcasts
  • Knowledge Base
  • Threecolts University
Connect
  • About Us
  • Wall of Love
  • Seller Advocacy
Become an
Agency Partner
Join Now
Join the
Affiliate Program
Join Now
★★★★★ 4.5 ★★★★★ 4.9 ★★★★★ 4.6

Blog

  • Blog
  • For Retail Vendors

Amazon 1P vs 3P: Which is better for your business?

Sell to Amazon or sell on Amazon? Compare margins, control, and cash flow before you pick a side.

Threecolts Staff

  • 7 min read
  • Nov 16 2026
  • Nov 16

  • 27
Amazon logo on a brick and mortar store

You have two ways to sell on Amazon. You can sell to Amazon (1P), or you can sell on Amazon (3P). The names sound like a technicality, but the choice changes who sets your price, when you get paid, and how much of each sale you keep.

The short answer: for most brands, 3P is the safer default. It’s open to anyone, you set your own prices, and 1P only happens if Amazon invites you. 1P can work for large brands that want hands-off volume and can wait for their money.

The marketplace side keeps getting bigger. Third-party sellers accounted for 61% of paid units on Amazon in Q3 2026, and that share has hovered between 60% and 62% for the past several quarters. This guide breaks down how each model works, what each costs, why Vendor Central is shrinking, and how to choose.

Amazon 1P vs. 3P at a glance

1P (Vendor Central)3P (Seller Central)
Who sells to the shopperAmazonYou
AccessInvite-onlyOpen to anyone
Retail priceAmazon sets itYou set it
Product pagesAmazon’s merchandising team handles changesYou manage them
FulfillmentAmazon handles itFBA, FBM, or Seller-Fulfilled Prime
PaymentCommonly 60 to 90 daysRoughly every two weeks
FeesWholesale discount plus co-op, allowances, and chargebacksReferral fee plus fulfillment and storage fees

What is Amazon 3P selling?

As a 3P seller, you run your own storefront through Seller Central. You list the products, write the content, set the prices, and choose how to fulfill orders. You can ship orders yourself (FBM), use Fulfillment by Amazon, or use Seller-Fulfilled Prime. 

(Our guides to Amazon FBM and Seller-Fulfilled Prime cover the non-FBA options.)

What you gain

  • Control over price, promotions, and listing content, with no waiting for Amazon to approve changes.
  • Better brand consistency across channels, since your price isn’t set by someone else.
  • Faster cash: proceeds typically arrive about every two weeks.
  • A higher ceiling on margin, since you keep the retail price minus fees.

What it costs you

  • Time and skill. You handle listings, ads, inventory, and (if you ship yourself) customer service.
  • Fees. Referral fees are 15% in most categories, with a $0.30 minimum. FBA fees rose an average of about $0.08 per unit on January 15, 2026, and a 3.5% fuel and logistics surcharge has applied since April 17. 
  • Less built-in trust. Shoppers see your brand name, not Amazon’s, so reviews and account health carry more weight.

For a professional seller account, the plan costs $39.99 a month plus selling fees. If you want ideas for running a 3P business well, see our 3P seller strategies.

What is Amazon 1P selling?

As a 1P vendor, you sell wholesale to Amazon through Vendor Central. Amazon sends purchase orders, takes ownership of the inventory, sets the retail price, and sells the product itself. Listings show “Ships from and sold by Amazon.com.”

What you gain

  • Bulk purchase orders on a predictable rhythm.
  • A hands-off operation: no pick-and-pack, no customer service, and no listing management.
  • The “sold by Amazon” label, which shoppers tend to trust.

What it costs you

  • Pricing control. Amazon sets the price, and its pricing can undercut your other channels and break your MAP agreements.
  • Margin. You earn a wholesale price, then deductions come out of it: co-op fees, allowances, chargebacks, and shortage claims. Estimates of those deductions range from a few percent to double digits, so check your own terms.
  • Cash flow. Payment terms commonly run 60 to 90 days, depending on your contract.
  • Stability. Amazon can end a vendor relationship, and it has done so at scale (more on that below).

Our guide to selling to Amazon through Vendor Central goes deeper on how 1P works day to day.

The money and how the math differs

Here’s a simple illustration, using round numbers (actual discounts and fees vary). Say a product retails for $30. On 1P, Amazon might buy it at roughly half of retail, so you receive about $15 per unit before your cost of goods. On 3P with FBA, you keep the 30 sale price, then pay a 15% referral fee (4.50) and an assumed $5.50 FBA fee. That leaves about $20 per unit before your cost of goods.

The gap shrinks fast on low-priced items, where fulfillment fees take a bigger bite. Run your own numbers before you decide.

Cash flow tells the rest of the story. If you ship $100K of product a month on 90-day terms, roughly $300K is waiting on Amazon at any given time. On a two-week payout cycle, far less of your money is tied up. A finance firm that studied both models estimated a 90-day cash conversion cycle on Net-60 vendor terms, compared with about 36 days on Seller Central with FBA.

The easiest way to compare is to track profit after every fee and refund. FeedbackWhiz Profits tracks fees and refunds next to revenue and shows profit by product, so you can see what your 3P products actually earn.

Vendor Central is shrinking

This is the biggest change since the old version of this guide. Amazon began mass-terminating vendor agreements in November 2024 and has kept sending notices in waves, mostly to small and mid-sized vendors. The most recent notices we found gave an August 2, 2026 termination date.

Amazon hasn’t published the criteria. Third-party reports suggest most affected accounts were below $5 million to $10 million in vendor revenue, but those are estimates. It also isn’t new: in 2019, Amazon cut off thousands of smaller vendors and nudged them toward Seller Central.

What does that mean for you? If you’re a small or mid-sized brand, don’t build your whole business on a 1P invite. If you’re already a vendor, build a 3P presence now, so a termination notice doesn’t leave you starting from scratch.

How to choose: 5 questions to ask

1. How strong is your brand? If shoppers already search for you by name, 3P lets you capture that demand and keep the margin. If you’re unknown, 1P’s “sold by Amazon” label can help, but only if Amazon invites you.

2. Can you handle the operations? 3P means managing inventory, listings, and (for FBM) customer service. If that sounds like too much, 1P is hands-off. But 3P with FBA can take much of the logistics off your plate.

3. How much cash can you tie up? 60- to 90-day terms are fine if you have the working capital. If you don’t, 3P’s faster payouts matter more than the sale price.

4. How big and heavy is the product? Bulky items cost more in FBA fulfillment and storage fees. On 1P, Amazon absorbs those costs, which can justify a thinner margin. Model both before you decide.

5. What are your channel plans? If you sell on your own site or other marketplaces, Amazon’s control over 1P pricing can cause trouble. If you want to expand across channels, 3P gives you room to set prices that make sense for each one.

Can you run both?

Yes, and plenty of brands try. One industry source suggests keeping high-volume core products on 1P and using 3P for launches, bundles, and seasonal items. It also claims nearly half of 1P vendors already run 3P accounts, though it doesn’t cite a source, so take that number with caution. We also couldn’t confirm Amazon’s current policy on running both at once, so check your vendor agreement.

If you do run both, plan for separate inventory, separate pricing rules, and clear ASIN assignments. SmartRepricer can handle the 3P pricing side with time-based rules and min and max prices.

How to get started

3P: Register for a Seller Central account, choose a plan, and start listing. Registering your brand in Amazon Brand Registry unlocks extra tools like A+ Content and Vine. 

1P: You can’t apply. Vendor Central is invite-only, and Amazon hasn’t published requirements. Third-party guidance points to things like manufacturer or distributor status, a strong sales history (often built first on Seller Central), and the ability to handle wholesale-scale orders. Given how much Vendor Central has shrunk, think hard before you chase an invite.

Which model fits you?

3P is the better starting point for most brands, because you can start today and you control your price, content, and cash flow. 1P suits large brands that prefer volume over control and can absorb long payment terms. Hybrid works for established brands that can staff both channels.

If you’re going the 3P route, Seller 365 puts the tools in one subscription: SmartRepricer for pricing, FeedbackWhiz Profits to see what each product really earns, and InventoryLab to manage inventory, plus seven more tools, starting at $69/month. Try Seller 365 free for up to 14 days or see the pricing.

Table of contents


  • Amazon 1P vs. 3P at a glance
  • What is Amazon 3P selling?
  • What is Amazon 1P selling?
  • The money and how the math differs
  • Vendor Central is shrinking
  • How to choose: 5 questions to ask
  • Can you run both?
  • How to get started
  • Which model fits you?

Grow your business with Threecolts

Discover the solutions making ecommerce more profitable than ever.

Get Started

Grow your business with Threecolts

Discover the solutions making ecommerce more profitable than ever.

Get Started
Continue reading...
  1. Yoda Yee
    Selling on Amazon is expensive. Is there an alternative?

    As Amazon’s fees increase and the market gets tougher, businesses are rethinking their options.

    Jan 3

    0
    Hand typing costs into a calculator surrounded by hundred-dollar bills
  2. Angela Apolonio
    How to sell on Amazon Canada: A step-by-step guide

    Amazon.ca shoppers are spending more than ever. Here’s how to get your share of the action without getting lost in cross-border chaos.

    Aug 15

    25
    How to sell on Amazon Canada - A screenshot of the Amazon.ca website
  3. Angela Apolonio
    What is a good RoAS on Amazon? (+ How to calculate it)

    If you don’t know your break-even RoAS, you’re flying blind.

    Sep 29

    31
    Good ROAS on Amazon - A glowing growth chart coming out of a smartphone representing Amazon ads
  4. Angela Apolonio
    9 must-have free tools for Amazon sellers

    Amazon gives new sellers a surprisingly robust toolkit for managing their business. Here are some examples.

    Oct 3

    73
    Free tools Amazon sellers - A laptop with code generating money, symbolizing profitability

Trusted by the best.
Find out why.

Get Started Get Started Book A Strategy Session Book A Strategy Session
Threecolts

Products

  • Margin Pro
  • Retail 365New
  • AI OperatorNew
  • UniCon
  • Seller 365
    • InventoryLab
    • Tactical Arbitrage
    • FeedbackWhiz Emails
    • FeedbackWhiz Alerts
    • FeedbackWhiz Profits
    • SmartRepricer
    • InventoryLab Accounting
    • ScoutIQ
    • Scoutify
    • ScoutX

Solutions

  • BrandsNew
  • Online Arbitrage
  • Retail Arbitrage
  • Wholesale
  • 1P Vendors
  • 3P Sellers

Services

  • Vendor Recovery
  • Seller Reimbursements
  • Carrier Optimization

Resources

  • Blog
  • Podcasts
  • Knowledge Base
  • Threecolts University

Partner

  • Partner Program
  • Affiliate Program

Company

  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Seller Advocacy
  • Wall of Love
  • Legal
Follow us:
System status © 2026 Threecolts. All rights reserved.